Does Pakistan really want international flood help?
Blogged by: Megan Rowling

Flood survivors clean an area near their damaged houses in Turbat, 550 km (344 miles) west of Karachi, Pakistan, July 2, 2007.
REUTERS/Mohsin Hassan
REUTERS/Mohsin Hassan
International disaster response is a more complicated beast than many people think. A country may be hit hard by floods or an earthquake, but that doesn't give the green light for the United Nations and other aid agencies to come charging in to help with relief. First, they have to wait for a sign from the government in question that outside assistance is wanted.
Often, this takes the form of an official request for international help. But sometimes, it's less direct. Rather than asking for assistance, a government will simply say it welcomes it. This is what has happened with the floods that have affected up to 2 million people in southern Pakistan in recent days, leaving some 250,000 homeless.
"China and India often do the same," explains Andrew MacLeod, a senior adviser on relief and recovery to the United Nations in Pakistan. "The government can see what is offered by international agencies and that can be measured against what is needed." So far, Islamabad has accepted relief goods such as medicine, water purification equipment and food.
The reasons why governments shy away from asking for aid vary. Often it's to do with politics - they want to be seen to be capable of dealing with their own disasters. Or it may be because the extent of an emergency is unclear at the beginning.
MacLeod says that, while this approach can lead to a smaller amount of international aid, in some cases it improves the quality because unwanted relief can be rejected. He cites the cost of having to burn surplus clothing after the 2005 quake in northern Pakistan, when the government did issue a formal request for help.
In the case of floods, working out the damage can be a real challenge when roads and communications are cut off, as has been the case in southern Pakistan.
"It's been difficult to get a full assessment. But on the current data, the Pakistan government is largely able to meet needs," says MacLeod. "If more information comes out, or we get a large weather system coming in, things could get out of their control."
The forecast is for more rain in the worst-affected provinces of Baluchistan and Sindh over the next three to four days.
The United Nations is sending its own disaster assessment team into the flooded region to better understand what's happening on the ground, and in preparation for further bad weather. And it's also hoping to persuade the government to agree to a U.N.-led appeal for funds to support the work of international aid agencies, which could be issued in the next day or two.
Meanwhile, the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (IFRC) has approved a grant of 250,000 Swiss francs ($206,400) from its Disaster Relief Emergency Fund for the emergency.
The Pakistan Red Crescent has just sent a six-person medical team to the badly hit district of Turbat, and water pumps and tanks have been provided for 800 families. In the coming days, IFRC plans to deliver 6,000 food packs in Baluchistan and 1,500 in Sindh - each containing a week of rations for a family of seven. Food prices have risen since the disaster, but shortages are starting to ease as some roads have reopened, and the military has stepped up efforts to bring in supplies by air and sea.
As is often the case with flooding, getting clean water to affected people is one of the biggest challenges, along with the prevention of water-borne diseases. The government has asked for anti-snake venom, to treat people bitten by snakes lurking in the floodwater. It also plans to procure 100,000 tents, as many homes have been destroyed.
"As just one example, in the village of Koshkalat near Turbat, 200 households have been completely wiped out, affecting 2,000 people," IFRC communications coordinator John Tulloch told AlertNet. "The problem is that many of the villages in that area are built on dry river beds, and houses are made of mud and thatch. They are not designed to cope with flooding, and the people are very vulnerable."
The damage wrought by this year's storms and floods will compound the region's already high levels of poverty. In Baluchistan, to complicate matters, there is a long-running conflict going on between the government and separatist militants, who are fighting for a greater share of political power and natural resource revenue.
Despite the government's flood relief operation and plans to launch a national appeal, there have been protests in Turbat over what local people see as a slow response to their plight. Aid agencies certainly need time to assess needs in the wake of a disaster, and where access is cut off, supplies may take days to reach affected areas. But Pakistan may also be struggling because its national disaster response capacity is relatively young.
When the 2005 earthquake hit the north, the military played a key role in distributing relief supplies. Thanks to that experience, the army has boosted its skills in humanitarian response.
But the National Disaster Management Authority, which was only set up at the end of 2006, has barely had time to find its feet. "It is still in the process of constructing itself, while having to deal with this (flooding) disaster," says MacLeod.
The NDMA is also mandated to work on measures to reduce the risk of disasters - and this year's floods are likely to underscore the importance of helping vulnerable communities protect themselves.
Reuters AlertNet is not responsible for the content of external websites.
8 responses to “Does Pakistan really want international flood help?”
Please note that comments should not be regarded as the views of Reuters.
Leave a Reply
When you submit a comment to us we request your name, e-mail address and optionally a link to a website. Please note where you submit a website address, we may link to it via your name. By sending us a comment, you accept that we have the right to show the comment and your name to users. Although we require your email address, this will not be published on the site, and is only required to enable us to check facts with you, e.g. if you are making a claim we can not confirm easily. Additionally, if you would like your comment removed at anytime, you'll have to use this e-mail address when you contact us. To remove a comment at any time please e-mail us at blogs-(at)-reuters-(dot)-com (address obscured to avoid spam) specifying who you are and what you would like removed. We moderate all comments and will publish everything that advances the post directly or with relevant tangential information. We reserve the right to edit comments in order to maintain the quality of the comments, and may not include links to irrelevant material. We try not to publish comments that we think are offensive or appear to pass you off as another person, and we will be conservative if comments may be considered libelous. Reuters will use your data in accordance with Reuters privacy policy. Reuters Group is primarily responsible for managing your data. As Reuters is a global company your data will be transferred and available internationally, including in countries which do not have privacy laws but Reuters seeks to comply with its privacy policy.





04 Jul 2007 13:15:32 GMT
the pakistan doesnt want the balochistan,s peoples they only want the land of balochistan , and they have chance now to fish balochi peoples , no need bombs no body tell them a guilty . we request the red cross and other agencies to dont give any thing to pakistani thieves , please send your own team on balochistan
04 Jul 2007 15:29:43 GMT
Balochistan need international help to day more than 250,000 baloch are homeles in just east Balochistan so callt pakistani Balochistan ,but in the same time people in west Balochistan so callt Iranian Balochistan also need international helpe becuse of floods Baloch people do not get any help either from pakistan or iran. please we rquest for helpe food, meddisen drinking water.
04 Jul 2007 15:30:36 GMT
Why should the Pakistani government ask for the international help? They want the whole Baloch nation to die so they can have Balochistan for them.
They have done that through military operations, the fifth operation is going on now. Why should they mind a help from the mother nature to eliminate the Baloch race. It is a pure genocide which the international community watching silently.04 Jul 2007 15:31:06 GMT
No, they don`t. The fifth military operation is going on in Balochistan. Pakistan has been conducting genocide against the Baloch nation, now they got the help from the mother nature, why should they deny it and ask for the international help for the nation they are trying to eliminate?
05 Jul 2007 11:48:07 GMT
It is known that pakistan is not wishing to help the flood effectives particularly Pakistani govt has become happy because the Balochs are deiying. pakistani Govt has used gunship helicopters and fighter jets and killed hundreds of innocent Balochs including women and children. Pakistani Govt have been looting the underground wealth of Baloch people since 1948 when Balochistan was annexet by force with pakistan. Now when Baloch people are suffering pakistani govt is wishing to collect the money from international community just for her own benifits. pakistani Govt will by use these money to kill and genocide the Baloch people. So it a request from Baloch nation not to give maney to Pakistani Govt, if international community is wishing to help the feeble Balochs so they should contact and give money to Balochs themselves.
Truelly Najeeb Marri Baloch Pakistan Balochistan, Kahan Kohlu Balochistan mailing address najeebmarri1@yahoo.com06 Jul 2007 08:59:09 GMT
Pakistani rulers have funds,soldiers,helicopters and jets to bomb & kill innocent Baloch civilians in Dera Bugti , Kohalo, Khuzdaar, Awaraan and in Turbat. Paki army has turned Balochistan to an army garrison.Recently paki army used 15 Helicopter & thousands of army men to capture one Baloch Wahed Kambar in the Tump area of kech distt. But it took the paki establishment five days to send only 1 helicopter in the same area.Most of the deaths have occured after the flood as there was no help or evacuation from the govt.Pakistan is ruled by ponjabi army is one of the most corrupt army in the world.Pakistan is the safe Heaven for Alqeda and Talabaan. Talebans &Alqaeda members are sposered, tarined and well equiped by paki army and sent to kill coalation forces across the border in afghanistan.Yet it is getting billions of Dollors to to be a partner in the war against terrorisam.pakies are not trust worthy.their recent behaviours ! within the country region and internationally is not of reiablity. There fore we the Baloch request the international Donors agencies, aid providers to come and help baloch directly in balochistan. The international team should not give a penny to paki govt. as it will not reach the Baloch. Please come in balochistan and help under your own supervision so the help goes to th needy one.. Thanks
09 Jul 2007 10:08:21 GMT
Paki Millitary Regime Got Billions oF Dollars,while the Kashmir was hit by an earthquake but the effectess still await rehabilition,one might ask where that money went,well into the pockets of generals of the army,international community should not repeat that mistake again and should directly fund and assist rehabiliation in Balochistan.The Ones Whom want Balochs to be wiped out of the face of the earth would never help at any cost rather they have choosed to save the cost of bullets and Bombs and let the flood and starvation kill them.
15 Aug 2007 12:07:31 GMT
It is a matter of great shame, that I heard the relief funds aimed for the poor and flood stricken miserable people of Pakistan (Baluchistan in particular) never reached those people and in fact was distributed amongst the government people and other administration and political people. It hurts me a lot. The feelings of my balochi brothers are justified when they show their anger and hatred towards the mainstream political and govt. leaders.
I humbly request these aid and relief teams to go to Balochistan and investigate these charges. And please help the poor flood victims. God bless you.