ZIMBABWE: Beef shortage provides
window of opportunity for swindlers
Source: IRIN
Reuters and AlertNet are not responsible for the content of this article or for any external internet sites. The views expressed are the author's alone.
HARARE, 10 August
2007 (IRIN) - It's early morning and a small truck with fake number plates draws upto a shopping centre in St Mary's, a populous suburb in the dormitory town of Chitungwiza - about 30km from
the capital Harare - and within minutes long queues form after the word spreads that there is beef for sale. Beef has become a rare commodity in the country and being sold at a price of Z$100,000
(US$0.40 at the parallel market exchange rate of Z$250,000 for US$1) a kilogram from the back of the truck, those queuing cannot believe their luck. When beef was readily available it was sold for as
much as Z$550,000 (US$2.2) a kilogram. After 30 minutes the truck has sold its stock and hurriedly disappears, and then it dawns on the customers that they have been duped and have bought donkey
meat, condsidered unedible by Zimbabweans. In rural Dema, which lies on the southern border of Chitungwiza, Chrispen Mutongi, 53, awoke to discover that his two donkeys had been stolen and alerted
the police, who later found the remains of his animals on a roadside in the dormitory town. They had apparently been killed and skinned the evening before the truck appeared at St Mary's,
making it possible that the meat sold as beef were his donkeys. "If the thieves had stolen goats or cattle and sold the meat, it would be understandable but that they had the guts to sell
donkey meat to unsuspecting people just shows how cruel these people can become in their quest to make fast money during these difficult days," Mutongi told IRIN. Mutongi used the donkeys in
tandem with his three cattle, but without them, Mutongi says he will not have sufficient draught power to adequately till his land next months when the rains are due and expects bad yields from his
crops this season, which will only add to his households worsening hunger. There has been a spate of livestock thefts in the Dema area and residents have now taken to keeping their goats and
chickens in their homes as a security precaution, whereas before the livestock would be housed in pens away from the homesteads. "Of course, we always experienced thefts particularly of poultry
but the cases have sharply gone up in the villages in the last month. What we have gathered is that those who steal the goats and chicken sell them in Chitungwiza and Harare," said Mutongi, who
is urging the police crackdown on the informal trade of meat products. Price controls It is just one more incident reflecting the increasing desperation among consumers, after President Robert
Mugabe's ruling ZANU-PF government introduced price controls six weeks ago in a bid to cap inflation levels that have surged beyond 4,000 percent, resulting in shop shelves becoming barren. According to the police 7,660 people have been arrested for overpricing after they failed to reduce prices by 50 percent since the price controls were introduced and beef and other livestock products
have all but disappeared from butcheries. When butcheries were ordered by price control taskforce inspectors to price their beef between Z$90,000 (US$0.36) and Z$120,000 (US$0.48) a kilogram,
abbattoirs stopped slaughtering arguing that they would be operating at a loss since they were still buying beasts at high price. The government revoked the abbattoirs' licences and brought the
parastatal, the Cold Storage Company (CSC), out of mothballs, and gave them the sole right to slaughter and distribute meat. But the CSC is struggling to meet demands, even though the parastatal
increased the price of a head of cattle from Z$3 million (US$12) to Z$12 million (US$48), still far short of the Z$40 million (US$160) price that were obtainable before the price blitz. "Now is
the time for the government to take stock of Operation Reduce Prices and revisit the rationale behind it against the negative implications it has had on consumers," Innocent Makwiramiti, a
Harare-based economist, businessman and past chief executive officer of the Zimbabwe National Chamber of Commerce (ZNCC) told IRIN. "That consumers can become so desperate as to fail to
distinguish between donkey meat and genuine beef reflects their vulnerability in an environment of extreme scarcity offset by bad policies. It is not only consumers but livestock owners as well who
are affected as unscrupulous people take advantage of the situation," he said. "Before the blitz, the CSC was not functioning and was hurriedly revived at a time private abattoirs were
closed down. It is poorly capitalised and lacks the necessary infrastructure for a massive rollout of beef. That means, for as long as there is no change in policy, beef will remain scarce in this
country," said Makwiramiti. The CSC said recently it required least Z$700 billion (US$2.8 million)to function properly, but as yet has only received a first tranche of Z$80 billion (US$320,000)
from the government. Poachers and rustlers At a time when drinking taverns are experiencing low patronage because of the unavailability of beer and meat, a butcher, who identified himself only as
Nick to IRIN has managed to maintain a constant supply of meat. "I did not cause the current shortage of beef and I will be the last to moralise about who brings me the stuff and where he or
she gets it. I have managed to strike it with some 'connections' of mine who give me regular supplies of both game meat and beef. "Of course, I know that some of the meat is poached
or rustled from farmers and rural cattle owners and even game parks, but it is the work of the police to investigate that," Nick told IRIN. Edward Mbewe, the Parks and Wildlife Management
Authority spokesperson, told the state-run Herald newspaper recently that the government was "concerned that the continued demand for meat now with our animals that are edible roaming our parks,
we could be seeing a worse poaching situation." When meat is sourced, it has often been transported in unhygienic conditions, but consumers care little for that or the legality of the meat. "When you have gone for a month without tasting beef, hygiene is the last thing that comes to your mind. There is a sense of victory when you manage to bring a morsel of meat to the table,"
John Mangirazi, a patron of one of Harare's taverns told IRIN. Nick is not deterred that if caught selling the meat of stolen animals that he could face a jail sentence of 30 years under strict
anti-rustling legislation. He sells a kilogramme of game meat for Z$600,000 (US$2.4), arguing that "the price monitors cannot touch me since it is not controlled", but even the beef he
sells at Z$450,000 (US$1.8) is above the gazetted price; although he does not expect to be arrested becasue he has "made friends" with the price control monitors. Conservationists believe
about 80 percent of Zimbabwe's wildlife population has been killed since 2000 when the government embarked on a controversial land redistribution programme that saw commercial farms owned by
whites redistributed to landless blacks. There have been reports of villagers hunting down elephants for food, particularly in areas close to nature conservancies, but smaller animals such as hares
and kudu are prime targets in rural areas. Beef has joined the ever growing list of shortages in Zimbabwe, which includes, fuel, electricty, potable water and staple foods. The Food and Agriculture
Organisation and the UN World Food Programme (WFP) issued a joint report on Zimbabwe's food security in June, predicting that "people at risk (from severe food shortages) will peak at 4.1
million in the first three months of 2008 - more than a third of Zimbabwe's estimated population of 11.8 million." The WFP made an urgent an US$118 million appeal on Wednesday to raise
funds for the millions of Zimbabweans facing severe food shortages. fm/go/he© IRIN. All rights reserved. More humanitarian news and analysis: http://www.irinnews.org









