Sun Nov 18 20:12:27 200717

Fetching...
 
YOU ARE HERE: Homepage > Newsdesk > Article
UK film in freedom of speech storm hits screens
06 Nov 2007 12:28:12 GMT
Source: Reuters
By Mike Collett-White

LONDON, Nov 6 (Reuters) - The makers of a new movie set in London's Bangladeshi community that infuriated community leaders and sparked heated debate about freedom of speech said the protests were unjustified and exaggerated by the media.

"Brick Lane", based on a novel by Monica Ali, appears in cinemas on Nov. 16, ending what the author called a "far from easy ride" on the journey from page to screen.

Cast and crew were forced to abandon shooting in Brick Lane after a small number of Bangladeshis living in the area complained, saying the book made them look simple and ignorant.

Concerned about a violent backlash, and acting on the advice of police, the film's backers moved to another area, although "Brick Lane" did return to the street in East London later on.

"It did make me angry, because we live in India and we always hail England as a country which allows freedom of expression," Tannishtha Chatterjee, the Indian actress who plays central character Nazneen, told Reuters in a recent interview.

Nazneen enters an arranged marriage and leaves her native Bangladesh for London and a new life with Chanu. After the attacks in the United States on Sept. 11, 2001, tensions between Muslim immigrant families and locals grow.

"This is a country which stood by someone like Salman Rushdie when there was a fatwa against him," Chatterjee said, referring to a 1989 death warrant from Iran's supreme religious leader after "The Satanic Verses" was deemed blasphemous.

"You have a right to protest (against) an expression, but we have a right to express that, so where is this right? That's what made me angry."

RUSHDIE VS. GREER

News of the protests and subsequent relocation were pounced on by commentators who condoned or condemned the protesters' actions, including Rushdie himself, who labelled author Germaine Greer's defence of the them as "disgraceful".

Ali accused the media of exaggerating the level of opposition among Bangladeshis and the level of threat posed, pointing out that opposition quickly petered out.

But her main concern was what she called "a marketplace of outrage", where no one dared argue with an offended minority, however small, meaning rational argument and debate was stifled.

"If offence is felt, the artist has no recourse," she said in a recent essay.

She added that the government had "shamefully" remained silent after both the "Brick Lane" incident and in 2004, when a play featuring sexual abuse within a Sikh temple was scrapped after a violent protest by Sikhs in Birmingham.

"Brick Lane" director Sarah Gavron pointed out that cooperation among Bangladeshis in the Brick Lane area far outweighed the number of protesters.

"Obviously as a creative person I absolutely believe in freedom of expression," she told Reuters. "Debate is all well and good, but ... an implicitly violent agenda isn't acceptable.

"We didn't back down, we just re-scheduled and came back and filmed later when those protests had died down."

Early reaction to "Brick Lane" has been mixed. While it won plaudits at a French film festival, some critics have accused Gavron of watering down the novel.

"You feel the book's guts have been lost, partly for budgetary reasons, partly out of an anxiety not to offend Britain's Bangladeshi community," the Telegraph newspaper wrote. (Editing by Stephen Weeks)
AlertNet news is provided by

Delicio.us  |   Digg  |   NewsVine  |   Reddit                                                                                  Permalink

Angola to hand over oil rebels to Nigeria for trial
Bangladesh cyclone toll tops 2,300, many missing
Nepal Maoists protest on eve of parliament session
Stench of death hangs over Bangladesh village
Bangladesh cyclone toll tops 2,200; many missing
ACT International supporting 35,500 people following Cyclone Sidr
Hilfe fuer Opfer von Zyklon Sidr in Bangladesch
UN Report highlights need for emergency carbon cuts programme, says Christian Aid
Thousands made homeless in WV Bangladesh ADP areas
Thousands made homeless in WV Bangladesh ADP areas
Thumb for /thefacts/imagerepository/RTRPICT/2007-11-18T155159Z_01_DHA17-_RTRIDSP_2_BANGLADESH-STORM_mainimage.jpg|/thenews/pictures/DHA17..htm
Thumb for /thefacts/imagerepository/RTRPICT/2007-11-18T154951Z_01_DHA16-_RTRIDSP_2_BANGLADESH-STORM_mainimage.jpg|/thenews/pictures/DHA16..htm
Thumb for /thefacts/imagerepository/RTRPICT/2007-11-18T154734Z_01_DHA10-_RTRIDSP_2_BANGLADESH-STORM_mainimage.jpg|/thenews/pictures/DHA10..htm
Thumb for /thefacts/imagerepository/RTRPICT/2007-11-18T154241Z_01_DHA12-_RTRIDSP_2_BANGLADESH-STORM_mainimage.jpg|/thenews/pictures/DHA12..htm
Thumb for /thefacts/imagerepository/RTRPICT/2007-11-18T153703Z_01_DHA18-_RTRIDSP_2_BANGLADESH-STORM_mainimage.jpg|/thenews/pictures/DHA18..htm

Storm survivors hug each other on the banks of the river Paira during their first meeting after the storm in Mirzaganj, 310 km (193 miles) from the capital Dhaka, November 18, 2007. Grieving survivors and rescuers picked through the rubble left in the wake of a super cyclone that battered Bangladesh as the death toll reached over 2,200 on Sunday and a government official declared the disaster "a national calamity". REUTERS/Rafiqur Rahman (BANGLADESH)



URL: http://www.alertnet.org/thenews/newsdesk/L0618783.htm

For our full disclaimer and copyright information please visit http://www.alertnet.org